Very Good Ballet Flats
A range of vetted options that can handle a healthy step-count while still looking stylish
Just because a shoe is flat, doesn’t mean it’s comfortable. As a working mom, I’ve mostly avoided heels for years in favor of flats, but finding a pair that’s truly comfortable can still be quite a challenge. I don’t mean just a shoe for short walks — I’m talking about one that hugs your foot like a glove, no blisters, no pinching, and enough support to leave your back thanking you at the end of the day.
After my last round-up of stylish and walkable city sandals, I received lots of requests to cover ballet flats next. I’ve been on a mission to test as many options as possible, seeking those that combine design with walkability.
I’ve also continued to wear my latest sandal acquisitions, and I can truly attest to these, these and these. I have been living in all 3 pairs along with my tried and true sandals by A.Emery.
Also! I am so excited to be featured in FT Fashion’s roundup of the best summer sandals — where I shared my insight and recommendations alongside a range of other standout picks.
My goal for this round-up is a curated list of flats that will suit various foot shapes and needs. From wider widths to cushioned insoles, comfortable and durable outsoles, here’s a selection of styles that are versatile, well constructed, and of course, stylish.
Heavyweight (15-20k Steps)
For those long days when comfort is non-negotiable.
I became obsessed with the cushioned footbed of Margaux’s sandals and that has now turned into a full-fledged obsession with all of their footwear.
These sleek maryjane flats have a padded comfortable footbed that makes a huge difference on those long days. The BEST part is that they offer narrow and wide widths, which is hard to come by in stylish footwear. I ordered the flat in the wide to test it out, and I am so grateful for the extra space. The shoe fits like a glove and I can really feel the cushioning underneath. I love the python print, it adds a nice textural interest but it’s still neutral and easy to wear.
Tip: Also check out Stuart Weitzman and Dolce Vita for extended sizes.
I’ve had these Alaia rhinestone flats for two years, and have definitely covered my cost-per-wear — as they surprisingly became my most comfortable shoe. I love that they are a little roomier in the toe box, so my toes don’t feel cramped. The leather lining and insole allows my feet to breathe, and lastly, the comfy rubber bottom and flexible construction give it an almost sneaker-like feel. I am not kidding when I say I can walk around all of Central Park in these, and not look like I’m exercising. Just low-key getting in my steps.
M.Gemi is another brand that I am pledging my allegiance to — as they make their footwear in Italy, and their leathers and components are beautifully crafted. I have been wearing this sandal for the past few weeks non-stop, and they never needed a minute to break-in! I am excited to wear these slightly square toed flats — the criss-cross feels like a fresh detail, and the cushioned footbed ensures comfort. I also love the stitching at the front, it adds an unexpected touch to the streamlined toe shape.
A reader recommended these flats — the two-piece bottom make them super comfortable and unique, and the super soft glove-like leather feels like butter. I tend to go for higher vamps as they feel more flattering on my foot. The coverage is just right on this pair.
I have been searching high and low for an elasticated shoe that feels more like a transitional shoe than a typical ballet flat. This pair is made from a supple lambskin leather and they feature a subtle square toe and strike the balance between flexibility and sturdiness. (I also love that the elastic isn’t too tight, which is ideal for me, as I hate when anything digs in).
Middleweight (recommend 10-15k steps)
For your daily wear — stylish and supportive, but not meant for a marathon.
Jamie Haller makes exquisite shoes — they may look simple at first glance, but the magic is in the way the shoes are built. These flats are made using a sachetto construction, which means the shoe wraps around your foot in one piece, creating a glove-like feel. While the padding is light, they’re perfect for a moderate amount of walking. I love how these flats pop when paired with neutral tones.
I love a bit of embellishment on my accessories, and these flats from Loeffler Randall are a perfect mix of playful elements — the mesh, the high vamp, and the metal studs come together to make a statement without being over-the-top. They are lightly padded, and seem to run a half size big, in my experience.
I have been eyeing these from Aeyde, and when a reader mentioned they are her favorite and most comfortable pair, I had to try them. Soft, unlined leather gives them an instant comfort factor, and the subtle almond shape is both modern and flattering.
I spotted these on the shoe floor at the new Printemps in Manhattan, and have noticed them around on many feet over the past couple of years. The sloped square toe and delicate strap make for a flattering, versatile flat that pairs easily with anything in your closet. I can see why it’s one of the brand’s iconic styles.
Ever since I saw the line of shoes by Le Monde Beryl, I have dreamed of having a closet full of them. Their soft, unconstructed flats are dreamy, and the higher V-shaped throat is flattering even for someone with larger feet like me. A padded insole made them even more comfy, and now they’re my go-to for daily wear. I got my first pair on the Real Real, and ordered my usual size. They were a bit big on me, so I decided in my quest for true comfort, that I would add an extra cushiony insole to see if they would fit me better. Turns out it worked perfectly, and it also gave me the added comfort I love. A great hack for upgrading a more stylish shoe into something that feels almost orthopedic.
I remember back in the day, when trying on shoes in the shoe store (remember the Nordstrom Shoe Salon?) was the only way to shop, and the shoe salespeople had little tricks to get a shoe to fit better. A bit of stretching, or those little half pads at the ball of the foot, the grippy heel pads at the back, and sometimes a full insole. I love these padded leather insoles because they look more refined than the standard Dr. Scholl’s.
I spotted these flats on a friend recently, as they are a more affordable alternative to the Le Monde Beryl flats, and she said they were incredibly comfortable. I especially love the burgundy haircalf and leopard print.
I haven’t tried any shoes from this brand, but in my deep-dive, I discovered they have this flat in so many beautiful suede and patent colors… and they are not too pricey! If anyone has tried them on or has a pair can you let me know how you like them? The fit, the quality, and most importantly, the comfort level?
OMG they also have these maryjanes…
I was walking around the city with Delphine Del Val and she was wearing these Repetto flats. I noticed the higher vamp and she said they also had a rubber outsole, I was sold. They don’t have much padding, but the sole is amazing. For days that I want a little more support, I slide in a pair of light insoles.
Lighterweight (5-10k Steps)
For when you're running errands or want a comfortable shoe for shorter outings.
These feel like a lightweight sheer stocking — and I love that. However, they don’t have any padding or much support to offer, but I forgive them since they are so ethereal and delicate, it would probably feel odd for them to be too built up.
These have always been a controversial shoe. I can’t tell if wearing flip flops on the streets of New York is more or less polarizing? Though I haven’t worn the Tabi flats on a full day’s walk yet, I’ve heard nothing but rave reviews for their comfort. They definitely deserve a place on this list. If anyone disagrees on the step-count for this style, please let me know!!
Mesh flats are an acquired taste, but I love them for their breathability and forgiving fit . Megan Alida Strachan posted this pair recently, and I picked up a pair in black as I know they will get a lot of wear. But they also come in fun colors like the red for a bolder statement.
This flat also comes in some beautiful suedes and this raffia pair too — perfect to cherish the remaining Summer days… I couldn’t resist ordering the green suede too — such an easy way to incorporate some color into an otherwise neutral wardrobe.
I came across these while shopping the other day, and they unfortunately didn’t have my size. I have a pair of their velvet slippers and love them - they are soft like a true slipper, so therefore don’t have the greatest support, but they are still comfortable flats, so long as you’re not doing any heavy walking.
Another glorious colorway from the same brand. These in a crinkled patent upper with a grosgrain binding.
Ok so I’ve always admired these crystal flats from Christopher Esber. Yes they do look like a bedazzled aqua shoe. But that’s ok. They have a delicate leather sole and a very open mesh upper, so I’d classify these as a fancy flat, not made for long walks, but they’ll elevate any outfit effortlessly. They are an investment piece but I feel like they are literally jewelry for your feet.
Speaking of jewelry for your feet… have you been seeing all the toe-rings (love these from Chan Luu).
With that, I hope you find the perfect pair that fits your feet, lifestyle and personal style. Would love to hear if you have any favorites or recommendations to add to this list.
x
In case you missed the sandal round up:
Thank you for being part of this space. If a paid subscription isn’t possible at the moment, you can still support this work in small but meaningful ways — like sharing this post, or joining the conversation in the comments, or in the chat. Whatever you choose, I appreciate you being here.
I occasionally include affiliate links - at no cost to you, but as always, I will only include links for pieces I already own and love, or would buy for myself. Thank you for supporting my work.
Find me on Instagram
First an epic sandal post, and now, my favorite of them all, ballet flats.
Joyce, you’re doing the lord’s work this Sunday. A wonderful and insightful read. Can you do the Mary Jane next?!?!
This is such a fantastic informative post. The mesh shoes remind me of these mesh, rhinestones studded slippers that Pearl River Mart sold, and I wore in the 1990’s The slippers were surprisingly comfortable for NYC streets.